At the end of the day, when there are no friends, when there are no lovers, who are you going to call for? What do you have to change?
–R.E.M., “Good Advices”
R.E.M.’s Fables of the Reconstruction was given the deluxe edition treatment this week–a remastered original CD and an extra CD featuring demos the band did in Athens just before flying to London to record the work with Joe Boyd. As deluxe editions go, this one is excellent simply because the second disk is not only a great listen but previously unreleased (for the most part), therefore making the whole thing worth purchasing even if you already own the album. And, yes, I bought my copy. When the first notes of “Feeling Gravity’s Pull” started up, I was suddenly taken back in time to 1985, to a point in my own musical history that has few parallels. Continue Reading »
I’m no musician; I’m more of a dabbler, really. But I create stuff and share it with others. One of the most common complaints I’ve received about my music is that it is too sparse–that there aren’t enough things going on. “It needs something….else,” a friend once told me. When pressed, he couldn’t identify exactly what was missing–just that there wasn’t enough sound there (or there there, perhaps). And he was probably right, but the problem with creating music is that each element added to a mix needs to blend with all the other elements. Add something, and suddenly everything else sounds different. More often than not, those added sounds just create a muddled mess.
It is so easy to create complex music today. There are endless tracks available in even the cheapest audio workstations; there are endless plug-ins that can be used to make every individual track different; and there are seemingly endless combinations within each plug-in to customize sounds even further. For many musicians (especially novices like myself), it seems almost like cheating if we don’t stretch the software to its breaking point, adding tweaks and overdubs and all sorts of variations to every single song, every single track, every single plug-in–whether they need it or not.
Most of the time, songs don’t need that level of complexity. A song is usually a pretty simple thing: a melody, a beat, a hook. But once those elements are figured out, the creative process kicks in, and it’s hard to stop tweaking, enhancing, expanding. Back when it cost real money to record music (studio time and all), there were good reasons to stop tweaking. Now? Money is no object; time is no object. But the end result often suffers.
Because I’m keenly aware of the pitfalls of overproduction, I find myself drawn to music that resists such complexity. I love artists that craft interesting music out of the most elemental sounds, artists who recognize that less is way more interesting (and more challenging) than more. I’m not talking about classical music or folk music that is designed for a quartet or a piano or acoustic guitar; that stuff is fine, but it’s designed for simplicity. There’s no challenge there. Rather, I’m talking about music that has been deliberately pared down to its basic elements. I’m talking about artists who create unique and memorable sounds and then have the guts to leave those sounds alone. I’m talking about artists like Young Marble Giants, whose entire output consists of simple beats, two-finger synth melodies, and simple guitar licks–crafted in utterly beautiful, brilliant ways. I’m talking about The White Stripes, who create epics out of a guitar, a drum set, and a voice. I’m talking about Tom Waits songs featuring an organ, a trash can, and his nearly-dead voice. I’m talking about Chris Watson’s wonderful recording of a cheetah’s growl. I’m talking about the minimalist orchestra music of Amiina. I’m talking about The Caretaker’s and William Basinski’s slowly-dying recordings of the past.
Most of all, however, I’m talking about Pan Sonic, the anchorite monks of electronic noise whose last album, Gravitoni, is released this month. If anyone embodies this aesthetic, it’s them.
My introduction to Pan Sonic came in 1999 with their third album, A. I was familiar with a lot of electronic music at that time–the typical stuff like Orbital, Autechre, Boards of Canada, Prodigy, Chemical Brothers, etc–but when the first hums and snaps of “Maa” (first track on A) came out of my speakers, something clicked. This is it, I thought at the time. This is what I’d been searching for (even if I hadn’t been aware of the search until that moment). I was amazed by the simplicity–low, resonating, overpowering tones; intense buzzing and wheezing noise; and especially the clean, crisp, snapping click beats. This is electronic music, music crafted from the very elements of electricity. I was enthralled. I went back and got their first two works, Vakio and Kulma. I picked up their live recordings. I picked up the solo work by Mika Vainio and Ilpo Väisänen. As each new album came out, I would spend weeks dissecting every second. I’d post reviews on my web site. I’d spread the word to whomever would listen. Before their four-CD set Kesto came out, I scoured the web looking for information on the work and then forwarded that information on to Phinnweb, the guys who ran the only Pan Sonic web site on the web. In fact, I scoured the Phinnweb Pan Sonic discography page and bought everything I could that had anything to do with the band, including a DVD that featured Pan Sonic performing on an instrument created by legendary Finnish electronic composer Erkki Kurrenniemi. The DVD was PAL-encoded, so I went out and bought a DVD player that played PAL disks (great investment–that thing let me buy the complete Blake’s 7 series that is only available on PAL).
Pan Sonic uses custom made instruments (made by Jari Lehtinen, a friend and unofficial “third member” of the group). I don’t know much about these, but I’m guessing they follow the rules for most synthesizers and drum machines–they use oscillators, filters, and envelopes; they feature sine and square waves and different types of noise. These various elements, configured in different ways, produce beats, tones, noises, and chords–the bread and butter of electronic music. But in Pan Sonic’s hands, these instruments manage to create beats, tones, noises, and chords that are richer, sharper, more interesting, and more “pure” than anyone else’s. Take the snare sound in “Vaihtovirta” off Aaltopiiri, for example. On the surface, it’s just a snap, like a thousand other snap sounds you’ll hear if you listen to enough electronic music. But listen again–there’s a warmth to that snap (created, most likely, by a built-in reverb in the instrument). At full volume (Pan Sonic’s preference), the snap sounds like a microscopic bullet shot into a thin sheet of ice.
What makes this sound even more impressive is way in which Pan Sonic presents it–sparsely. Their music is incredibly simple: some beats, some tones, and some noise. There are usually only about four or five different sounds at work in a Pan Sonic song; some of the sounds are in the high frequencies, some in the mid, and some in the low. Rarely do sounds overwhelm one another; each one is given space to build and to inhabit its frequency range. As a result, that snare snap in “Vaihtovirta” is wonderful because we can focus on it so easily. I find interesting sounds far more exciting than interesting songs, so this focus on sound alone is infectious. That’s not to say that Pan Sonic’s music merely fills space, however; the songs and the song structures are equally compelling, often moving from silence to noise and back again within a simple three-or-four minute opus. This was made possible, in part, because Pan Sonic usually recorded their music live in studio–unlike almost every other electronic artist (or just artist, for that matter, since the advent of computer recording equipment). That live feel in their music allowed for spontaneity, to be sure, but it also brought a freshness to the feel of the music–the sense that only music created in a moment can provide (mistakes and all).
Above all, however, I am amazed by Pan Sonic’s consistency. Everything they have every created is memorable. Yes, their music shares some common elements across every one of their albums, and some might call that repetitive. However, I don’t. To me, they are craftsmen who use the same tools and the same elements to create as many different, unique, and ingenious works that they can. Their biggest album, the four-CD Kesto, was founded upon the triptych works of Francis Bacon, who routinely created three different paintings on the same subject as a way to explore the many faceted nature of those subjects. To me, Pan Sonic’s music (not only Kesto but all of their works) took up a similar exercise–to explore how many different ways they could use the same basic tools to create music. If you listen to all of their music, from 1995′s Vakio to 2010′s Gravitoni, you’ll hear an incredible range of sounds and musical styles, from minimalist techno to maximalist noise.
And now we have an answer to the question: how many years can Pan Sonic use the same elements to create new musical ideas? The answer is: 15. Yes, Gravitoni is (apparently) their last album as a group. The two have been solo artists for some time now, and they both plan to go their separate ways to pursue their individual interests. But before they went away entirely, they gave us an amazing album that functions like a concluding chapter in the Pan Sonic story. Like all good conclusions, this one summarizes everything that came before and offers a final parting thought by which to remember their legacy. So spread across this album’s eleven songs and 52 minutes, there are beautiful and ugly and terrifying beats; overpowering caverns of noise; deep, gurgling bass lines; waves of sonic steam; and sine waves and square waves and flashing waves and distressed waves and on and on. Some of the highlights include “Corona,” which must be the audio equivalent to a voyage into the sun; “Radio Qurghonteppa,” which features a killer bass line (grinding gears churning through dead bodies, I think); and “Kaksoisvinokas/Twinaskew,” an eerie song that includes actual vocal samples (very rare in the Pan Sonic world).
And then there’s the last track, “Pan Finale” (see above), which really does sound like a finale, encompassing every single one of these sounds in an almost montage-like way to end the album and their career, starting with propulsive beats, adding in techno noodles and waves of spooky tones, then pushing these tones further and further towards a wall of noise and distortion, grinding and churning around the beat, washing us in a bath of white death. This is followed by a pause, where the beats and noodles reemerge; followed again by a powerful buzzsaw noise of pain, which dies into a long, slow tone that moves from left to right and back again as it dies. And, in the very end, at the very last second, there’s a snap, a crunch, a burst of noise–and then silence.
In all, Gravitoni is an amazing end to an amazing career. I’ve been listening to it for over a week and find myself wanting to go back and re-listen everything that this band has created. To me, as a wanna-be musician, their music is both inspiring and intimidating. I hope someday to create beats that are half as good as theirs–and when I do, I hope I have the guts to then leave those beats alone to grow and build and to live within my songs. Mostly, however, I’m humbled by their ability to follow a musical path for such a long time and with such amazing success.
I know nothing whatsoever about the producer/artist Joker–save for the fact that his music is awesome, he’s a he, he’s from the UK (specifically, Bristol), he’s released stuff on Hyperdub, he has an album coming out. And Mary Ann Hobbs loves him.
His “Digidesign” was one of the best songs of last year, and his new song “Tron” is one of the best songs of this year. He’s usually linked to the dubstep scene, but when I think of dubstep, I think depressing music (Burial, Kode9, stuff like that). Instead, I lump Joker’s music in with Flying Lotus and Hudson Mohawke, artists that take the elements of dubstep and hiphop and fuse them together with the sounds of an imaginary 1980s science fiction universe (Weird Science, Tron, Electric Dreams, The Last Starfighter). Big, bold colors and bouncy patterns rip through the music, like a procession of roller coasters experienced by kindergarteners on a sugar high. Everything is big and exciting and bouncy and fun in Joker’s universe, and that’s why his music makes for such an enjoyable listening experience.
So I’ll shut up now and let his music do the talking. Enjoy.
Here’s a song I created for my Berklee Music class on Ableton Live. The voices are taken from an episode of The Outer Limits (new series) entitled “Music of the Spheres.”
It’s here! It’s Joanna Newsom’s brand new 3-CD, 2 hour opus, Have One on Me. Her last album, Ys, was one of the finest works of the last decade, and I’ve been waiting and waiting for new music from her to come out ever since I first heard “Emily.” And now my wait is over, and now the listening begins. Hopefully, I’ll have something to say about the work in a few days.
Angels win 2002 World Series–At my father’s funeral in 2005, I talked about our shared love of sports, and the point I made to illustrate this love was him calling me after the Angels won the Series for the first time. That’s how much this meant to me (and to him).
The Wire: When a postmortem is written about the American experiment, this show will be singled out as a perfect illustration of how the country fell. The detailed way in which the show demonstrated corruption, complacency, and stagnation at all levels of bureaucracy and business, mixed with the systematic defeat of anyone and everyone trying to make things better, says more about the last decade than a million hours of campaign commercials and governmental panels ever could. It’s the most essential work of art of this century, and it will be one of the lasting gifts of our generation to generations to come.
William Basinski‘s The Disintegration Loops and The River–I helped to generate interest in William Basinski’s work when I worked at the now-defunct Stylus Magazine. All of his work is wonderful, but these two works shine above all other music from the last decade (even though they both are really over 30 years old now).
Children of Men: The best film of the decade is also the most amazing science fiction films ever conceived. Clive Owen’s acting, Alfonso Cuarón’s directing, and Emmanuel Lubezki’s cinematography are the three pillars in this film, which takes us on a journey through a world without children and all the chaos and confusion that this fact produces. It’s a spellbinding, amazing work of art.
Barak Obama–2nd best night of the decade (behind the night the Angels won the series) was the night that Obama won the Presidency. And while he’s been attacked left and right for the past year, he’s still standing and he’s moving slowly but surely toward change. I still believe.
Apple’s iPod and iPhone–When I used to carry around a portable CD player and 50 CDs, I would dream of a device that could store my music in my pocket. And then I got an iPod. And then I got another iPod. And then I got an iPhone. And then I gave my first iPhone to my friend and got a new one and we both started using ours together. And it was good.
Tivo–Oh hell yes.
Idiocracy–Funniest movie of the decade, and the most accurate. We don’t have to wait 500 years for this world to come into existence; I see this kind of stupid every single day.
Sigur Rós‘s Agaetis Byrjun, ( ), Takk…, and Hvarf – Heim–Band of the decade? I think so. Their music has defined much of the genre that is usually known as “post rock,” even as their emerging popularity has alienated the band from the critics, most of whom see the band as sell-outs because they are successful. And yes their last album wasn’t as good as their previous work; but it’s still way better than 99.99% of all music ever, so I’ll give them some slack. Oh, and Amiina is awesome too!
Joanna Newsom’s Ys–I put this CD in my car shortly after I bought it in 2007 and it’s still in there. It’s one of the only examples of high-quality poetry brought to life through music.
The Venture Brothers–Poetry of an entirely different stripe, this series is the vanguard of Adult Swim, itself the vanguard of popular entertainment for quite some time. It’s part Hardy Boys, part Superfriends, part Six Million Dollar Man, part dada, part I Saved Hitler’s Brain, and part…well, part everything else I can come up with. Oh my flipping zombie Jesus is this show good.
Tod Dockstander’s Aerial–Decades in the making, this is a magnum-opus from an electronic music pioneer who never really had much of a chance to practice his art back in the 60s because he lacked the credentials to use the very rare and very expensive technologies found in some high-level universities and few other places. This is an exceptional trilogy of albums that puts Dockstander front and center in the modern world of experimental music.
Netflix–It took me a while to get into this (their initial catalogue was rather minimal), but now it’s practically a religion, even for people like my mom who know next to nothing about computers. She checks her email and her Netflix queue. Oh, and they forced Americans to use the word “queue,” too. That’s awesome.
The Caretaker: The Complete Digital Collection–Unbelievably important music from the guy who was originally known as V/VM. The entire catalogue is worth owning; more than that, it’s affordable. This guy pioneered the online distribution of music. Most of his catalogue was originally available for free download. But I felt that I owed it to him to buy the collection and support this wonderful artist’s work into another decade (which has begun in earnest with Leyland Kirby’s latest release).
World of Warcraft–This is #1 on my wife’s “Bottom 10″ list for the decade. I play it too much–and have for several years. I got hooked when I saw that I could create a druid alchemist. How cool is that? Not that alchemy or druidism in WoW have anything to do with actual druids or alchemy, but it’s still fun to imagine living within a mythological world.
Boards of Canada‘s Geogaddi and The Campfire Headphase–Boards of Canada’s contribution to the music world in the last decade consists of two fascinating albums and some EPs. These are exceptional works, and they extend the ideas from Music Has the Right to Children in interesting ways. I still check BoC’s website every day to see if there’s news of their latest release. I bet I’m not the only one.
Amazon Prime–I grew up in Riverside, about 60 miles from Los Angeles at a time when I had to go into LA to find any decent music or bookstores. I dreamed of a day when I would live in a decent town where I could buy any of the weird stuff that I read about in magazines. And then the Internet showed up and with it came Amazon, the first and still best stop for online shopping. I now live in a town that is over 100 miles from the nearest pocket of civilization, and the only reason a place like this is even partially tolerable is Amazon Prime, which allows me to buy whatever I want and not pay for shipping (well, I pay $75 a year, but you have no idea how much stuff my wife and I get on Amazon).
Neal Stephenson’s Anathem–Read it recently and loved it. I’ve loved all of his novels (though the Baroque Cycle is a tough haul). I love the fact that the kernel of this novel’s story is taken from the Long Now project.
Tim Hecker‘s Radio Amor, Harmony in Ultraviolet, and An Imaginary Country–I first got into Hecker because Amour was based around shortwave radio signals he recorded in Central America (shortwave being one of my fascinations). But everything this artist has created in the past few years is truly beautiful and challenging (a difficult combination, indeed). Highly recommended.
Stow, Scotland–My wife and I took our parents to the UK in 2006. We spent a week at a small farmhouse in this town. It was wonderful.
Ableton Live–This is the past, present, and future of electronic music composition. This German company will dominate the next decade because of their wise decision to merge their software with Cycling ’74′s epochal Max/MSP. Max for Live debuted in November 2009 and will be the basis for more music in the coming decade than the vocoder was in the Noughts.
Top Gear–I care very little about cars, but I love this show. It proves that adult men can make fun of each other intelligently and with style. Plus it’s one of the few things my wife and I enjoy watching together.
Lord of the Rings–The movies were fantastic, but what I love even more is the fact that these films spearheaded the interest in fantasy and mythology. It’s partly because of this film that I’m able to teach a class on mythology at my college.
Patton Oswalt–I’ve been a fan since his 1996 HBO special (which I taped and watched over and over). He’s more popular than ever now, and his comedy just keeps getting stronger.
Longplayer–A wonderful idea. Here’s hoping it lasts!
Bottom 10
George W. Bush
Dick Cheney
Donald Rumsfeld (really, it’s a three-way tie for first)
Rush Limbaugh/Glenn Beck/Fox News
People who don’t understand the difference between “were” and “where”
Terrorists of all stripes (from the 9/11 attackers to the Wall Street thugs to Republican fearmongers)
Rather than pick and choose between different albums, I’m focusing on artists here. Sigur Ros released a lot of music in the past decade, and it’s all (or nearly all) worthy, so I just lump it all together here in the #2 spot. The same goes for Basinski, The Caretaker, Boards of Canada, and so on. Mind you, I don’t add everything by these artists–only the cream of their crop (so to speak). My attitude is: why focus on one work when so many great artists created multiple works of incredibly high quality?
As a result, I think you’ll find that the top albums list comes out to about 29 individual works (and more, if you count The Caretaker’s work individually). That doesn’t include the multiple-CD releases here like The River and Kesto. What does this mean? Despite the near-death of the music industry, there’s still a hell of a lot of great music out there.
When The Commitments came out in 1991, I was a 23 year old English grad student obsessed with both James Joyce and soul music (especially Otis Redding and Bobby “Blue” Bland), so you know that Alan Parker’s film (based on Roddy Doyle’s wonderful novel) would be a big hit for me. I saw it twice in the theater, I believe, and each time I had to pinch myself. How did they know? I asked myself. How did they manage to create a movie just for me? Continue Reading »
I think all of The Replacements music has been reissued in deluxe or expanded editions. REM is doing that as well, as have Sonic Youth, Pavement, and so on. And even bands that hail those acts as influences (Nirvana, Radiohead, etc) have gotten their music reissued in expanded editions.
So where the hell is the reissue of Double Nickels on the Dime by The Minutemen? This is one of the finest albums from the 1980s, and just as influential and as loved as all that other music. It hasn’t been released for ages. In fact, in the CD era, it hasn’t really been fully released. The version that is out now (the one on iTunes and at Amazon) is missing two tracks (and is in serious need of remastering).
So forget about reissues; how about an issue? Please please someone (whoever is in charge of stuff like this) take it from a record buyer: remaster this puppy and give it back to the world. We needs our Minutemen!